Skip to main content

Quilter Cheviot challenges investment trusts to keep raising standards as review reveals mixed progress

Date: 19 November 2026

4 minute read

19 November 2026

Following its in depth engagement programme in 2023 and 2024, Quilter Cheviot has found a mixed level of improvement as it has revisited the investment trust sector to analyse progress in corporate governance practices and responsible investment disclosures.

The engagement primarily focuses on three factors for improvement:

  • Board composition – boards should be independent, diverse and have the right skillset.
  • Board effectiveness - boards should have the ability and willingness to challenge the investment adviser, when necessary, carry out external evaluations and ensure strong communication with shareholders.
  • Responsible investment disclosures - that are pertinent to the investment trust and provide real-life examples of how the trust approaches stewardship and the integration of environmental, social and governance factors within its investment process.

Quilter Cheviot once again provided each investment trust with a red, amber or green rating on the three criteria.

The overall picture is mixed with a net change of red, amber and green ratings of -5 (21 deteriorations compared to 16 improvements), although this is partly due to higher expectations today around responsible investment disclosures. There are however, only two trusts which are red across all three assessed categories, whereas previously it was four, while three maintained their all-green rating.

Within the board composition factor, over the period there has been a minor improvement, with a 20% reduction in red ratings and a 44% increase in amber ratings, whilst the green rating remains static. The key concerns remain - manager representation on boards, over-tenure and not meeting the FCA diversity targets. Notably, there has been significant progress in the reduction of manager representatives on boards, although some remain entrenched in the view that the manager must have a representative on the board. In one case the non-executive director (NED) fee is paid to the manager.

There has been significant improvement in the board effectiveness rating (46 green ratings compared to 38 previously), however, some trusts continue to fail to disclose the details of which firm was employed to undertake the external evaluation, or in some cases do not have an external evaluation at all or far exceed the triennial requirement.

Meanwhile, there has been a marked deterioration in the responsible investment disclosure ratings, with more trusts in the RED category than previously – 16 compared to five. This reflects a new scoring methodology so is not a strict comparison, although is also representative of changes made by trusts following the introduction of the Sustainability Disclosure Requirements and some being deterred from including metrics in the fear that they may be caught out by the rules.

In contrast to the previous reports this engagement focused on reviewing the annual report and accounts of 59 investment trusts which fall into Quilter Cheviot’s centrally monitored investment universe, across equities, alternatives and property.

Quilter Cheviot plans to continue monitoring progress and focusing on shareholder value for money, appointment practices of NEDs and whether a trust has a senior independent director or not.

Gemma Woodward, head of responsible investment at Quilter Cheviot, said: “We would not claim to be solely responsible for changes in the way that boards approach the three factors we engaged on, however we know that in some cases we have been instrumental in change. Ultimately, we believe that as shareholders we have a responsibility to hold boards to account and to use the voting mechanism to elicit change where appropriate.

“Crucially, there is an ongoing realisation that having a manager representative on the board creates all sorts of conflict of interest. There are still improvements to be made on this front as well as responsible investment disclosures, and we hope some of the other innovations investment trusts have been embarking on, especially around a board’s effectiveness, can be applied to other elements of its operations.”

Matt Ennion, head of fund research at Quilter Cheviot, added: “Investment trusts remain a vital part of the toolkit available to portfolios. However, given the publicity of activist investors, the number of trusts having wound down and the lack of new ones coming to market, it is crucial that the current universe works for shareholders.

“Investment trust boards need to make sure they are acting in the best interest of shareholders, and it is pleasing to see progress being made in some key areas. But, if a healthy investment trust sector is to survive into the future, more needs to be done to make them attractive relative to other fund structures and to attract a wider investor base. We look forward to continuing this work and engaging with the sector to help drive improvements that should ultimately create more value for shareholders.”  

Gregor Davidson

Senior External Communications Manager

About Quilter plc

Quilter plc is a leading wealth management business, helping to create brighter financial futures for every generation.

Quilter plc oversees £160.5 billion in customer investments (as at 30 September 2026).

It has an adviser and customer offering spanning financial advice, investment platforms, multi-asset investment solutions and discretionary fund management.


The business is comprised of two branded segments: Quilter and Quilter Cheviot.

Quilter encompasses the financial advice network and national, Quilter's investment platform and multi-asset solutions and Quilter Invest, the digital savings and investment app.

Quilter Cheviot is a discretionary fund management and financial planning business.

This press release is for journalists only and should not be relied upon by financial advisers or customers.

Please remember that past performance is not a guide to future performance. The value of investments and the income from them can go down as well as up and investors may not get back any of the amount originally invested. Exchange rate changes may cause the value of overseas investments to rise or fall.

This communication is issued by Quilter plc.  Registered office: Senator House, 85 Queen Victoria Street, London, EC4V 4AB, United Kingdom. Registered number: 6404270.  Registered in England.

PRIVACY INFORMATION

We hold your name, email address, job role and the name of your publication on our Press Distribution List and use this information to send you press releases which we believe will be of interest to you. You can stop receiving emails from us at any time by emailing us at: pressoffice@quilter.com and asking us to remove you from the Distribution List.